[It] seems to exist only to answer the unasked question "What would "I Spit on Your Grave" have been like if the main character had been Martha Stewart?"

Mikati never settles on whether he's steering an identity crisis drama or an exploitative vengeance fantasy.

For most of the way, "Return to Sender" merges creepy and sexy to good effect, thanks to a close-to-the-vest performance by Rosamund Pike, the missing wife of "Gone Girl."

Return to Sender, starring Rosamund Pike, isn't quite what it seems...